Hi,
I had this thought the other day after watching a TV.
A priest at a church. Would you trust the Priest?
If yes, then if the Priest tells you God spoke to him, would you believe the Priest?
If yes, then the Priest tells you that God told him to kill unbelievers, would you believe the Priest?
If no, then please explain why?
If yes, and the Priest does the act and is arrested. In court the Priest has to swear on the Bible and he tells the courtroom that God told him to do it. Would the jurors believe the Priest and find him not Guilty.
1
Would You Believe A Priest?
Started by
Capt-Zeanie
, Apr 01 2018 11:25 AM
18 replies to this topic
#1
Capt-Zeanie
-
- GS Member
-
- 338 posts
Goblin
- Gender:Male
- Location:Malvern, UK
- Interests:Paranormal, Computer Programming, IT, Web Technologies, Space and Astronomy
Posted 01 April 2018 - 11:25 AM
--
Sean aka Capt Zeanie
Sean aka Capt Zeanie
#2
MrsFrootloops
-
- Root Admin
-
- 2,382 posts
Lead Moderator
- Gender:Female
- Location:My House
- Interests:Anything artistic, baking, cooking, waffles, comics, games, hamsters, and um, things lol.
Posted 01 April 2018 - 12:24 PM
I don't trust humans in general.
#3
siguie
-
- GS Member
-
- 1,179 posts
Earthbound Spirit
- Gender:Male
Posted 01 April 2018 - 04:32 PM
I think you are trying to discuss an example of defeasible reasoning and in this case looks like you are trying to imply an argument from authority situation.
In the end this kind of thing is where "trust" becomes a question of belief in particular what is stronger their belief in the faith, the priest or themselves/moral values etc.. The same would be true for the juror situation though I don't think swearing on a bible changes anything.
In the end this kind of thing is where "trust" becomes a question of belief in particular what is stronger their belief in the faith, the priest or themselves/moral values etc.. The same would be true for the juror situation though I don't think swearing on a bible changes anything.
- siguie -
#4
MacCionoadha BeanSidhe
-
- GS Member
-
- 4,587 posts
Alien
- Gender:Not Telling
- Location:Underworld
- Interests:Meat Loaf(Actor/Singer not the food), Paranormal, Reading, Beading, Baking, Barbecuing, Cooking, Container Gardening and Music.
Posted 01 April 2018 - 06:02 PM
I'm not too keen about these type of questions, but I'll answer.
A priest at a church. Would you trust the Priest? - I'd need to know that person for a very long time before I'd really trust him.
If yes, then if the Priest tells you God spoke to him, would you believe the Priest? - Possibly, again I'd really need to know him/her before I could give a reasonable answer.
If yes, then the Priest tells you that God told him to kill unbelievers, would you believe the Priest? - No way, I wouldn't believe it on God's good green Earth.
If no, then please explain why? - There is no reason to kill unbelievers. IMO, that type of thinking is sick and twisted, that would be no different than what Hitler did.
If yes, and the Priest does the act and is arrested. In court the Priest has to swear on the Bible and he tells the courtroom that God told him to do it. Would the jurors believe the Priest and find him not Guilty. - There is no way that anyone with even a mote of sanity, would condone that kind of slaughter, just because a person doesn't believe in the same God you do.
A priest at a church. Would you trust the Priest? - I'd need to know that person for a very long time before I'd really trust him.
If yes, then if the Priest tells you God spoke to him, would you believe the Priest? - Possibly, again I'd really need to know him/her before I could give a reasonable answer.
If yes, then the Priest tells you that God told him to kill unbelievers, would you believe the Priest? - No way, I wouldn't believe it on God's good green Earth.
If no, then please explain why? - There is no reason to kill unbelievers. IMO, that type of thinking is sick and twisted, that would be no different than what Hitler did.
If yes, and the Priest does the act and is arrested. In court the Priest has to swear on the Bible and he tells the courtroom that God told him to do it. Would the jurors believe the Priest and find him not Guilty. - There is no way that anyone with even a mote of sanity, would condone that kind of slaughter, just because a person doesn't believe in the same God you do.
Edited by MacCionoadha BeanSidhe, 01 April 2018 - 06:03 PM.
Aquène kah nahonnushagk(Peace and farewell),
WaûtuckquesSóchepo (SnowRabbit)
The Unofficial GhostStudy Easter Bunny
#5
Snickers
-
- GS Member
-
- 238 posts
Ghoul
- Gender:Female
- Location:Ohio
Posted 01 April 2018 - 06:48 PM
He's lying, lock him up and throw away the key!
Don't tell me that I didn't see what I saw, or didn't hear what I heard.......Snickers
#6
Vlawde
-
- GS Member
-
- 12,082 posts
Exorcism
- Gender:Male
- Location:Fair Oaks Ca
- Interests:Music, games, movies, the paranormal
Posted 01 April 2018 - 07:13 PM
I have no good reason to trust a priest any more than anyone else. Less so if they claim god told them things
#7
KlaineyGStudy
-
- Root Admin
-
- 5,034 posts
Forum Manager
- Gender:Not Telling
, I wouldn't believe the Priest. I wouldn't think the jurors would either. 
#8
JYMSUN
-
- Root Admin
- 8 posts
False Positive
- Gender:Male
Posted 05 April 2018 - 09:46 PM
Snickers, on 01 April 2018 - 06:48 PM, said:
He's lying, lock him up and throw away the key!
Evil Priest
#9
MacCionoadha BeanSidhe
-
- GS Member
-
- 4,587 posts
Alien
- Gender:Not Telling
- Location:Underworld
- Interests:Meat Loaf(Actor/Singer not the food), Paranormal, Reading, Beading, Baking, Barbecuing, Cooking, Container Gardening and Music.
Posted 06 April 2018 - 11:06 PM
We have a friend who is a priest, which is why I said, " I'd need to know that person for a very long time before I'd trust him."
Aquène kah nahonnushagk(Peace and farewell),
WaûtuckquesSóchepo (SnowRabbit)
The Unofficial GhostStudy Easter Bunny
#10
MichelleGStudy
-
- Moderators
-
- 2,486 posts
Moderator
- Gender:Female
- Location:Beaufort, NC
- Interests:I am in private practice with a primary focus on treatment & management of eye disease. I enjoy astronomy, paranormal Investigating, visiting cemeteries, geocaching, gold panning, metal detecting & things of that nature.
Posted 07 April 2018 - 05:24 PM
Interesting topic - it makes you think.
#11
earthlydelitesGStudy
-
- Moderators
-
- 5,006 posts
Moderator
- Gender:Female
- Location:Sydney
Posted 07 April 2018 - 11:54 PM
a good defence lawyer would probably look for a plea of insanity to remove the need for a jury....
It's in the trees, it's coming!
#12
MacCionoadha BeanSidhe
-
- GS Member
-
- 4,587 posts
Alien
- Gender:Not Telling
- Location:Underworld
- Interests:Meat Loaf(Actor/Singer not the food), Paranormal, Reading, Beading, Baking, Barbecuing, Cooking, Container Gardening and Music.
Posted 08 April 2018 - 05:05 PM
Most likely.
Aquène kah nahonnushagk(Peace and farewell),
WaûtuckquesSóchepo (SnowRabbit)
The Unofficial GhostStudy Easter Bunny
#13
daphnerose
-
- GS Member
-
- 396 posts
Goblin
- Gender:Female
- Location:Columbia River Gorge
Posted 08 April 2018 - 05:37 PM
Can of worms!
#14
moiraesfate
-
- GS Member
-
- 2,482 posts
Doppelganger
- Gender:Female
Posted 09 April 2018 - 09:18 AM
Being a priest doesn't make that person any more trustworthy than anyone else. So would I? No. There are very few people in the world that I actually trust.
Edited by moiraesfate, 09 April 2018 - 09:18 AM.
#15
MrsFrootloops
-
- Root Admin
-
- 2,382 posts
Lead Moderator
- Gender:Female
- Location:My House
- Interests:Anything artistic, baking, cooking, waffles, comics, games, hamsters, and um, things lol.
Posted 09 April 2018 - 09:57 AM
I don't even trust myself half the time, I have made some very bad decisions that turned out ok, but were really stupid of me to do, and I survived them (thankfully). So yeah, you can't put total trust in anyone.
#16
LouczarGStudy
-
- Moderator
-
- 807 posts
Moderator
- Gender:Male
- Location:New Braunfels, TX
- Interests:WOW, our dogs and hanging with good people!
Posted 10 April 2018 - 02:02 PM
Trust has to be earned....not given freely. For me anyways.
Anyone who tells me to do anything bad to another would be in the Dont Trust column.
If the priest killed someone...how could the jury find him not guilty? Even if God told him to do it...It's still murder.
Anyone who tells me to do anything bad to another would be in the Dont Trust column.
If the priest killed someone...how could the jury find him not guilty? Even if God told him to do it...It's still murder.
Just because you have one....doesn't mean you have to act like one - Louczar
Life is short, enjoy it!
Life is short, enjoy it!
#17
Sody
-
- GS Member
- 30 posts
Spirit
- Gender:Male
- Location:WA
- Interests:Geocaching, Hiking, Photography and Gaming.
Posted 15 April 2018 - 04:38 PM
I don't think a priest would be more trustworthy. People often use religion to manipulate or harm people. Not saying that religion is bad of course, but the way that a lot of people use it as a guise certainly makes me slow to trust.
#18
KlaineyGStudy
-
- Root Admin
-
- 5,034 posts
Forum Manager
- Gender:Not Telling
Posted 16 April 2018 - 02:59 AM
#19
Acea
-
- GS Member
- 7 posts
False Positive
Posted 16 April 2018 - 06:25 PM
If a preistt was told by "god" to kill I would have to assume that it wasnt god who intructed him, but a negitive entity manipulating the priest.....
